Skip to main content

Trying to Save Taxpayer Money? Drug Testing for Public Benefits Probably Isn’t the Answer (Even if it Were Constitutional)

This week has seen many news headlines discussing legislation to ensure that people using public programs are not also on drugs. At least eight states are looking to require testing before people can receive TANF, food stamps, or even unemployment. In Pennsylvania, several representatives are looking to introduce legislation requiring testing for welfare recipients.

So what’s the problem? The ACLU points out that drug testing of welfare recipients is flawed policy from three standpoints:
  • Fiscally: The drug test itself averages around $42 per person, not including personnel costs. If costs are measured by the number of people “caught,” they could range from $20,000-$77,000 per person – much more than what is spent on the amount of benefits received (the TANF cash grant has not been increased since 1990, when it was set at between $365 and $421 per month depending on the county a family resides in).
  • Scientifically: Drug testing services note that tests don’t usually catch “hard” drug use, such as methamphetamine or cocaine. And they definitely won’t catch alcohol abuse. In fact, the states that have considered mandatory drug testing have found something as simple and noninvasive as a questionnaire can detect 94% of drug use, and often the use of alcohol as well.
  • Constitutionally: All of this, of course, is something of a moot point: in 2003, the 6th Circuit of the Supreme Court ruled that random, suspicionless drug testing of welfare recipients was unconstitutional.
When we are looking to spend our public dollars wisely, the answer doesn’t appear to lie in the direction of drug testing, but in increasing access to job training, career counseling, and other important programs.


Popular posts from this blog

Are You Registered to Vote?

As we get closer to the November elections, Google searches on how to register are increasing, which begs the question: Are you registered? Do you know how to sign up?

Pennsylvania and many other states require voter registration before Election Day - in Pennsylvania's case, voters must be registered one month ahead of time.  So if you recently moved, just turned 18, haven't voted in a while, or never registered before, the time to sign up is now.

PathWays PA has partnered with Rock the Vote to offer voter registration through this blog! You can fill out the form below to register or to make sure that you are registered.

Please take the time to register, and also consider pledging to vote in support of your economic values at!

PS - click here to share a voter registration link on Facebook, Twitter, or Google+!

Register Now for National Audio Conferences on Job Scheduling

From our friends at CLASP Register now for three national audio conferences on job scheduling! Job schedules matter in many ways. For all workers, it helps when an employer is responsive to a request for a needed schedule change. And far too many workers have volatile and potentially destabilizing schedules. If you don't know when you are supposed to be at work until the last minute, how do you arrange child care or transportation? If your total hours fluctuate from week to week, how do you budget for rent and food? To address these issues and emerging policy opportunities, the Center for Law and Social Policy (CLASP) is hosting and sponsoring three Job Schedules Matter audio conferences.

The conferences, which are co-sponsored by the Center for Popular Democracy and the National Women's Law Center, will include comments from U.S. Senator Elizabeth Warren and Congressman George Miller on why they introduced the Schedules that Work Act. You'll also hear from workers about th…

Register for FRAC's Federal Nutrition Program Conference Calls

The Food Research and Action Center (FRAC) will host two public conference calls in October. Information on the calls follows below:
Breakfast Matters - Effective Messaging: Getting Positive Press in your Community

Thursday October 11, 3 – 4 pm ET
Click here to register.
Learn tips from a national communications firm about how to place your stories with local media and receive positive press coverage for your program.

Presenters: * Jon Dickl, School Nutrition Director, Knox County Schools, Tennessee
* Amber LaCroix, BRG Communications

Afterschool Meals Matter - Community Partnerships
Wednesday, October 17, at 1:00 pm EST

Click here to register.
Learn how you can connect with a myriad of community partners, from parent groups to corporate volunteer programs, who can offer you and your program their time, energy, and support. Community partners can assist you with meal preparation, programming, outreach to increase your participation, and ultimately to help build up community support and in…